Wednesday, November 18, 2026

The Abyssinian Baptist Church: McGruder, McFarlane-White, Ball, and Mason Sr. v. Abyssinian lawsuit dismissed 11/6/2026

 Two years ago, Abyssinian called Rev. Dr. Kevin R. Johnson to lead us. Since then, more than 670 new members have joined our church family, and we have opened the Dr. Calvin O. Butts III Educational and Cultural Center to serve Harlem.

On November 12, 2026, the New York State Supreme Court, Appellate Division, First Department, unanimously affirmed the dismissal of the lawsuit challenging the 2024 pastoral election, confirming that Pastor Johnson was duly elected by this congregation.
We thank God for the fruit of these years, and for our members, staff, diaconate, and trustees who have labored faithfully throughout. We are also grateful to Atty. Brian Pete and Lewis Brisbois for their expert legal counsel, and to LaToya Evans and the The LEPR Agency for standing with us through every step. The best is yet to come.
“See, I am doing a new thing! Now it springs up; do you not perceive it?” (Isaiah 43:19, NIV)
Now let us keep building together. God is doing a new thing at Abyssinian, and there is a place in it for every member of our church family.
Abyssinian United: Growing Deep, Growing Wide.
Read the full statement at abyssinian.org/dismiss.


//////////////////////////////////////////

Standing on Truth, Transparency, and Faith

The Abyssinian Baptist Church is committed to keeping our congregation and community informed with clarity, integrity, and respect. This page provides accurate information regarding recent legal matters involving the Church that have been fully and decisively dismissed by the courts.


Members of Abyssinian Baptist Church:

On November 12, 2026, we learned that the New York State Supreme Court, Appellate Division, First Department unanimously upheld the dismissal of the McGruder, McFarlane-White, Ball, and Mason Sr. v. Abyssinian lawsuit, affirming the December 2025 dismissal. Today’s decision ends the last lawsuit brought against the church related to the 2024 pastoral election and closes a challenging chapter for Abyssinian Baptist Church.

We are grateful to see this journey end, and we look forward to continuing to grow and bring souls to Christ while upholding the legacy we’ve built in Harlem and beyond. This is a pivotal time in our church’s history, and I am thankful to God for seeing us through.

Thank you to every member and friend of Abyssinian who has supported the church during this process, including our staff, diaconate, and trustees. Thank you also to our public relations team, LaToya Evans and the LEPR Agency, who stood by us as we navigated this process. I’d also like to thank our legal counsel again, Atty. Brian Pete of Lewis Brisbois, who has expertly represented Abyssinian through each of these election-related lawsuits, and whose insight and guidance have allowed us to remain victorious in this fight.
As we close this chapter, we hold fast to God’s promise in Isaiah 43:18–19:

“Remember ye not the former things, neither consider the things of old. Behold, I will do a new thing; now it shall spring forth; shall ye not know it?”

Our eyes are fixed on the new thing God is doing at Abyssinian. True to our theme for this year, Abyssinian United: Growing Deep, Growing Wide, we invite every member of our church family to walk into it together.

Keep the Faith,
Rev. Dr. Kevin R. Johnson
Senior Pastor

Dismissed: Appellate Court Unanimously Upholds Pastoral Election

The Appellate Division, First Department, has unanimously affirmed the dismissal of the lawsuit challenging the election of Rev. Dr. Kevin R. Johnson as the 21st Senior Pastor of The Abyssinian Baptist Church. The Court held that the Church’s Bylaws require election by a majority of votes cast, and that the petitioners’ remaining claims were conclusory and speculative.
This decision reaffirms the will of the congregation and the integrity of the Church’s governance process
Read the Full Decision (November 12, 2026)
READ THE PRESS RELEASE
Recent Lawsuits Dismissed
Update on the Appeal: McGruder v. The Abyssinian Baptist Church

On September 9, 2026, counsel for The Abyssinian Baptist Church and Rev. Dr. Kevin R. Johnson filed the Church’s response to the appeal of the lawsuit challenging his election as the 21st Senior Pastor. The brief asks the Appellate Division to uphold the Supreme Court’s dismissal of the case.

The response reaffirms that the congregation’s June 2024 vote was conducted in accordance with the Church’s Bylaws.
Read the Brief (September 2026)
New York Supreme Court — Election Challenge


The New York Supreme Court has dismissed the lawsuit challenging the election of Rev. Dr. Kevin R. Johnson as the 21st Senior Pastor of The Abyssinian Baptist Church. The Court found no legal basis to overturn the duly conducted election of the congregation.
This ruling affirms the Church’s governance process and the integrity of its democratic decision-making.


Read the Press Release
Supreme Court Dismisses Lawsuit Challenging Pastoral Election

Status: Dismissed in Full on December 19, 2025

On December 19, 2025, the Supreme Court of the State of New York, New York County, dismissed the lawsuit challenging the election of Rev. Dr. Kevin R. Johnson as the 21st Senior Pastor of The Abyssinian Baptist Church. The Court found no fraud or wrongdoing in the June 2024 election and upheld the congregation’s vote as conducted in accordance with the Church’s Bylaws.
Dismissed: McGruder, et. al v. Abyssinian
Federal Court Dismisses Employment Discrimination Claims

Status: Dismissed in Full on March 31, 2025



On March 31, 2025, a Federal Court dismissed all claims brought against The Abyssinian Baptist Church related to alleged employment discrimination. The Court ruled that the claims were barred under the First Amendment’s ministerial exception, which protects a church’s right to make decisions regarding its religious leadership without government interference.



The Court’s decision confirms long-established constitutional protections afforded to faith institutions.
Dismissed: Turman Marshall v. Abyssinian


0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home